Web App vs Mobile App: Which Should You Choose for Your Business?

The Often Misasked Question

Many clients come to us asking: "We want to build an app — Android, iOS, or a website?" While this sounds simple, it contains an underlying assumption that needs to be checked first: is an app actually the best solution for your business problem?

After assisting various businesses in Indonesia — from FMCG, agribusiness, and fintech to government sectors — we have compiled a simple framework to help you make this decision more accurately.

Understanding the Core Differences

Web App

Accessed via a browser (Chrome, Safari, Firefox) without requiring installation. It can be built as a Progressive Web App (PWA) so it can be "installed" on the home screen and function partially without internet.

Examples: Figma, Notion, Google Docs, browser-based admin systems.

Native Mobile App

Installed from the App Store (iOS) or Google Play (Android). Can access device hardware features: camera, GPS, push notifications, accelerometer, NFC.

Examples: Gojek, Tokopedia, WhatsApp, banking apps.

Cross-Platform App (React Native / Flutter)

A single codebase that can be deployed to both Android and iOS simultaneously. More cost-efficient than native, with nearly comparable performance for most use cases.

Suitable for: Startups that need broad coverage with a limited budget.

Decision Framework: 5 Key Questions

1. Do your users need access to hardware features?

Camera, real-time GPS, push notifications, sensors, NFC, Bluetooth — these are the domain of mobile apps. If your product relies on these features, a mobile app is almost certainly the right choice.

Use case example: Field sales apps with GPS attendance, QC apps with inspection photos, delivery apps with real-time tracking.

If you don't need hardware features? A web app or PWA will suffice — with far more efficient development costs and time.

2. How frequently will users use your product?

Users who open your app more than 3–4 times a week will feel much more comfortable having a mobile app on their home screen. Users who open it occasionally (monthly, or for specific tasks) don't need the hassle of installing an app — a web app is better for them.

Rule of thumb: Daily/weekly use → mobile app. Monthly/task-based use → web app.

3. Who are your users — internal or external?

For internal users (employees, operations teams), distribution and updates via a web app are far easier than pushing updates to hundreds of individual employee devices.

For external users (customers, the general public), a mobile app offers a smoother and more familiar experience — especially in Indonesia, where smartphone penetration is very high but browser usage habits are comparatively lower.

4. What is your budget and timeline?

Realistic development costs:

• Web app: Rp 30–150 million, depending on complexity (one codebase, one platform)
• Cross-platform (React Native/Flutter): Rp 60–200 million (covers Android + iOS)
• Native Android + iOS: Rp 120–400 million (two codebases, two teams)

If budget is limited: start with a web app or PWA, validate the product, and build a mobile app only if demand is proven.

5. Do you need distribution via the App Store?

Some businesses rely on their presence in the App Store and Google Play as part of their legitimacy and brand trust — particularly in finance, health, and e-commerce sectors. If this is your business, a mobile app is not just a technical choice but a positioning necessity.

Our Recommended Approach: Build-Validate-Expand

For startups and businesses new to digital, we almost always recommend a phased approach:

1. Phase 1: Web app or PWA — validate core features, gather real user feedback, and prove product-market fit. Minimal cost and time.
2. Phase 2: Mobile app (cross-platform) — once traction is proven, release to Android and iOS. You now have real user data to guide feature priorities.
3. Phase 3: Platform optimization — native app or premium platform-specific features, based on the usage data collected.

This approach avoids the worst-case scenario: building an expensive mobile app that goes unused, or discovering that users don't actually need the mobile features you imagined.

Real-World Case: When We Recommend a Web App

A client in the agribusiness industry needed a daily field reporting system for 30 field officers. They initially wanted a mobile app because it "looked more professional." After analysis, we recommended a PWA accessible via a browser that could be pinned to the home screen.

The result: development was completed 40% faster, feature updates could be pushed in real-time without asking all field officers to update the app, and adoption was 100% in the first week because there were no installation barriers.

Discuss Your Needs

There is no universal answer. Every platform decision must start with a deep understanding of your users, use cases, and business context. The Colabs team helps clients make this decision from the early consultation phase — without an agenda to push for a larger project than you need.